Tadalafil (CIALIS) vs Sildenafil (Viagra) – Is One Better?

Comparing Tadalafil (Generic Cialis) and Sildenafil (Generic Viagra)

Man choosing between generic medications for erectile dysfunction

When patients visit our clinic seeking effective relief from erectile dysfunction (ED), they often face an important and initial choice between two popular medications: tadalafil, marketed as Cialis, and sildenafil, commonly known as Viagra. Historically, the cost of these medications was a significant hurdle, as they were both under patent protection and came with hefty price tags. Patients frequently found themselves navigating the frustrating landscape of insurance approvals and denials. Fortunately, with the advent of generic versions, these medications have become significantly more accessible, allowing a broader demographic to benefit from their potent efficacy. We often recommend that patients experimenting with ED medications for the initial time try both tadalafil and sildenafil separately, as this allows for a personalized assessment of which drug is more effective with the least side effects for them. Given the reduced pricing of these generics, there is minimal financial concern for patients eager to discover which medication suits their individual needs best, taking into account personal health conditions and lifestyle factors.

Comparing the Mechanism of Action

Dr. Engel Seminar Promo

Both sildenafil and tadalafil function as phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE-5) inhibitors. This classification signifies that they inhibit the enzyme phosphodiesterase type 5, elevating intracellular levels of cyclic GMP, which enhances blood flow to the penis upon sexual arousal. It's essential for patients to understand that these medications do not augment sexual drive or libido; rather, they facilitate the mechanics of achieving and maintaining an erection when the desire is present. Furthermore, while these medications have been shown to be effective for many patients, it’s crucial to acknowledge that they are not infallible, and the overall success rate can be influenced by various factors, chiefly the underlying degree of erectile dysfunction. Patients should also keep in mind that as erectile dysfunction may evolve over time, there may be instances where dosages need adjustment, and a significant portion of individuals who initially respond favorably to these pills may experience diminished effectiveness as their condition progresses.

Comparing Which Works Faster

Both tadalafil and sildenafil typically require about 30 to 60 minutes before they begin to exert their effects, allowing men to achieve the anticipated erection. However, peak drug concentrations in the bloodstream are achieved at different intervals; tadalafil reaches its peak level around two hours post-ingestion, while sildenafil does so in about one hour. Consequently, we recommend patients take these medications approximately one hour or two before engaging in sexual activity. Individual responses may vary, making it wise for patients to rely on their own past experiences as a reference for timing.

It's also important to note that sildenafil's effectiveness can be compromised by the consumption of large meals, particularly those high in fat content, which is not a concern for tadalafil. For those in committed relationships with predictable intimacy, sildenafil may be a preferred option, as the timing can be more easily controlled. Conversely, tadalafil might be more suitable for individuals who are dating and may encounter numerous social dining situations where heavy meals could hinder sildenafil's effectiveness.

Comparing Which Lasts Longer

In terms of duration of efficacy, tadalafil has a distinct advantage over sildenafil. While sildenafil remains functional for about four to six hours, tadalafil can sustain its effects for up to 36 hours after consumption, which is particularly beneficial for younger patients or those experiencing milder forms of ED. It's important to clarify that neither of these medications enhances sexual desire—rather, they merely improve the ability to achieve an erection when one is desired.

Comparing Side Effects

As is the case with any pharmaceutical agent, both sildenafil and tadalafil come with their own set of potential side effects. In general, however, both medications are well-tolerated by the majority of users, with adverse effects typically being mild and transient.

Patients using sildenafil may experience headaches, nausea, facial flushing, nasal congestion, and, on occasion, digestive issues or dizziness. Another notable side effect can include a blue tint to vision. Most side effects are mild and often resolve once the medication is discontinued. However, in rare cases, sildenafil can lead to severe complications, such as loss of vision, particularly in individuals with pre-existing eye disorders or those with cardiovascular conditions like hypertension, high cholesterol, and diabetes, as well as smokers, who may be at an elevated risk of complications.

On the other hand, those taking tadalafil may also experience side effects such as headaches, indigestion, and nasal blockage, but may additionally report distinct symptoms like back pain, coughing, and upper respiratory tract infections. Interestingly, findings from recent scientific studies suggest that while both medications can induce side effects, they may also be associated with a potential reduction in the risk of premature mortality due to cardiovascular disease by up to 25%. It is essential to emphasize that these medications are not intended to treat heart disease and should not be used as substitutes for any existing cardiovascular treatments.

Overall, both sildenafil and tadalafil possess a relatively mild risk profile, but it’s important to note that the duration of side effects experienced with tadalafil may last longer due to the prolonged presence of the drug in the bloodstream compared to sildenafil.

Comparing Drug Interactions

When receiving a prescription for ED medication, healthcare providers will invariably inquire about any concurrent use of nitrates, such as nitroglycerin or recreational “poppers” that may contain amyl nitrate. This is critical, as the combination can lead to a sudden and potentially dangerous drop in blood pressure, resulting in serious complications like heart attacks or strokes. Generally, patients on these medications already face significant cardiovascular risks, making the use of ED drugs especially precarious. It's imperative for patients to initiate discussions with their healthcare providers or pharmacists regarding any other medications currently being taken to ensure a safe regimen while using ED medications.

Does Either Medication Reverse ED?

Dr. Engel often likens the progression of erectile dysfunction to a roller coaster ride. Initially, the decline toward ED occurs gradually and imperceptibly. However, once it begins to interfere with sexual performance, the descent tends to accelerate in a manner that is not typically reversible. While ED medications may provide temporary relief by improving blood flow to the penis, the underlying vascular health issues associated with ED usually worsen over time as men age. As a result, there will ultimately come a point when these medications might no longer facilitate satisfactory erections, at which stage it may be necessary to explore alternative treatments, including injections or penile implants.

Which Makes You Harder?

Studies indicate that while both tadalafil and sildenafil can yield similar quality erections, a slightly higher proportion of men reported achieving satisfactory erections with sildenafil.¹ Nevertheless, due to tadalafil's longer duration of action, it may be favored by a more considerable number of men, enhancing both convenience and spontaneity of intimate encounters.

The Bottom Line

Considering the current low prices of generics, Dr. Engel firmly believes that there is no singular ED medication that suits every patient universally. As highlighted, each drug has a distinct benefit and risk profile, necessitating a thorough discussion during your consultation. With the affordability of both options, most patients can safely acquire and experiment with both sildenafil and tadalafil to ascertain which is most effective for their distinct needs. Should any side effects arise with either medication, it is advisable to discontinue use and switch to the alternative. If side effects are severe or persist beyond a reasonable timeframe, prompt medical assistance should be sought without hesitation.

Reference:

1Doggrell SA. Comparison of clinical trials with sildenafil, vardenafil, and tadalafil in erectile dysfunction. Expert Opin Pharmacother. 2005 Jan;6(1):75-84. doi: 10.1517/14656566.6.1.75. PMID: 15709885.